It might not be as bad as otherwise reported.
A recent study conducted by the University of Basel and the Technical University of Munich challenges the widely held belief that the blue light emitted by smartphones, tablets, and computers significantly disrupts natural circadian rhythms. Published in the journal Nature, the study focused on the impact of calibrated blue–yellow changes in light on the human circadian clock. Over the course of an hour before bedtime, 16 participants were exposed to three types of light: blue-dim, yellow, and constant white background/control light. Surprisingly, the study found no conclusive evidence supporting the idea that changes in light color along the blue–yellow axis have a significant effect on the human circadian clock or sleep.
While light, in general, can disturb human sleep patterns, the study challenges the notion that modern devices may have as detrimental an impact as previously believed. The human eye processes light through cones, rods, and intrinsically photosensitive retinal ganglion cells (ipRGCs). Blue light, common in devices like smartphones, is converted to the color blue by cones, responding to bright light, while rod cells operate in low-light conditions without distinguishing between colors.
The study emphasizes that ipRGCs in the eye primarily focus on light intensity rather than color and play a crucial role in regulating circadian rhythms. The photopigment melanopsin, expressed by ipRGCs, helps control nighttime melatonin suppression. While cones convey information to ipRGCs, suggesting that light color could impact circadian rhythms and sleep, the study challenges previous assumptions.
The findings highlight the complexity of the brain’s process in modulating internal circadian rhythms. Dr. Alexander Solomon, a surgical neuro-ophthalmologist, suggests that reducing overall exposure to bright light, rather than relying solely on blue light blocking, might be beneficial. Despite the study’s insights, caution is advised against unrestricted device use before bedtime, as the research’s specific design may not fully align with real-world lighting conditions.
Neuroscientist Keiland Cooper from the University of California, Irvine, underscores the need for more research to fully understand how devices affect health. Cooper emphasizes that understanding the precise mechanisms influencing neural functioning is crucial for designing devices that promote better sleep and mitigate side effects. In conclusion, the study challenges previous assumptions about the negative impact of blue light but highlights the ongoing need for comprehensive research to understand the nuanced effects of device usage on sleep and overall health. Existing recommendations for screen hygiene, such as avoiding screens altogether before bedtime, remain relevant pending further insights from ongoing investigations.
Discussion about this post